I recently designed a cup-shaped part (it's a bracket) that I tried to slice and print with v5.1.2. Applying an FDM process for a Makerbot Replicator 2 in the Preview I saw the slicer adds a plane across an cup-shaped curved surface facing the positive Z axis.

Here you can see the the first z-layer where this errant plane shows up; it shows up a bridge feature. Stepping up z-layer by z-layer, it looks to be 5 layers thick (1mm in my case):

Here's the same part correctly sliced with v4.1.2, note how the bridging feature/plane is absent:

Happy to send you the part as an stl or 3mf if you'd like to investigate yourselves!